SC – Asset Reconstruction Co & Section 138 Prosecution of Original Lender Bank
Comments on the post of Abhishek Sharma and the Judgment dated of the Supreme Court in Special Civil Petition (Criminal) No.20619 of 2026 of Kishore Avarsekar and others Vs. Assets Care and Reconstruction Enterprises Ltd and others
In the present case, there exists an assignment agreement between the original lender19 and the first respondent which, inter alia, refers to and includes the three post-dated cheques issued by the petitioners to the original lender, since dishonoured, the cheque return memos, and the demand notice under Section 138, N.I. Act, along with conferment of the right to institute, continue and enforce legal proceedings including the pending complaints.
What appears on a bare reading is that Section 5 permits an ARC21 to acquire the financial assets of a bank/financial institution. In terms of sub-section (1), inter alia, it could be by entering into an agreement for transfer, on such terms and conditions as may be agreed upon between them. Sub-section (2), which serves as the foundation for sub-section (4), provides for substantive vesting of rights. By a deeming fiction, on acquisition of the financial assets by transfer, an ARC becomes the lender and all rights of the bank/financial institution vest in it. Sub section (3) ordains that all contracts, deeds, bonds, agreements, etc. relating to the asset continue to remain in force in favour of the ARC. While sub-section (4) is the law providing for procedural continuity, sub section (5) governs the procedural aspect for the tribunals, courts and other authority to abide by when approached by an ARC with a request for substitution. Such substitution, however, is subject to the requirement thereunder that the application be made with the consent of the originator.
rsue the remedies 21 asset reconstruction company 6 available to the original secured creditor in relation to the financial assets so acquired. The right to continue proceedings would, however, be subject to compliance with the requirements of the statute governing that particular proceeding or remedy.
- 15. Whether, sub-sections (4) and (5) of Section 5, authorise the ARC to seek substitution in a pending complaint under Section 138, N.I. Act necessarily has to be answered by meaningfully construing the expression “other proceeding of whatever nature relating to the said financial asset is pending by or against the bank or financial institution” in sub-section (4) and “for the purpose of substitution of its name in any pending suit, appeal or other proceedings” in sub-section (5).

