No Proof, No Penalty of Forfeiture of Pension
Forfeiture of 100% Pension & Post-Retiral Benefits – Disciplinary Enquiry
The writ petition was appointed as Assistant Engineer in 1985 and retired on 31.3.2021.
On 17.11.2021, the writ petition was given charge sheet of five charges relating to the period when the respondent worked as Superintending Engineer at NOIDA.
The Inquiry Officer, while returning its findings and recommendation, observed that, had the respondent been in active service, it would have warranted major punishment leading to his termination, but since the respondent had retired, hence the recovery be made from his post-retiral dues and also recommended for forfeiture of his pension.
From the bare perusal of the inquiry report, it would reveal that it holds charges to have been proved, but how and upon what evidence or material the said charges were held to be proved, to arrive at the said conclusion, is conspicuously absent. In other words, the inquiry report does not indicate as to what documentary evidence (as mentioned in the charge-sheet) was considered to prove which charge.
It would also be relevant to state that the nature of the punishment awarded, relating to forfeiture of his entire pension required serious approach with which the charge ought to have been proved, a casual approach could not have been adopted. Even otherwise, before passing a SPLAD No. 704 of 2026 9 punishment order relating to forfeiture of the pension, at least a finding ought to have been returned as to how the department had been put to financial loss by the delinquent employee and to what extent. In the entire inquiry report or even in the punishment order, there is no material to indicate as to how the respondent was guilty or responsible for causing any financial loss to the department. The record would indicate that in the inquiry report, the material considered is all based on certain estimate and vague assertions and it cannot partake the nature of cogent evidence unless proved and connected to the charges levelled.
Bar Bulletin and the Judgment dated 17.11.2026 of the High Court of Allahabad at Lucknow in Special Appeal Defective No.704 of 2026 of U.P. Power Corporation Ltd Vs. Rakesh Kumar

