Mere Consumption of Toddy Not Sufficient to Reject Accidental Death Claim
Judgment dated 27.10.2026 of the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Consumer Complaint No.117 of 2025 of Smt.Machha Rajini w/o late Machha Mahendra Kumar and others Vs. SBI General Insurance Company Ltd and others
The opposite parties, under the slogan “Suraksha Aur Bharosa
Dono,” attracted the deceased, Macha Mahendra Kumar, to obtain
insurance coverage. Accordingly, the deceased obtained a Personal
Accident Insurance Policy for a sum insured of Rs. 20,00,000/- by paying
a premium of Rs. 1,000/-
t is further averred that the deceased, Macha Mahendra Kumar,
accidentally fell into the water of a village tank and died due to drowning
on 30.03.2025, leaving behind the complainants as his legal heirs. In
connection with the said incident, the Jakanpally Police Station registered
a case in Crime No. 47 of 2025 and issued FIR under Section 194 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS). During the course of
investigation, the police conducted an inquest panchanama and recorded
the statements of witnesses. On the basis of the statements recorded
during the inquest, it was opined that the deceased had accidentally fallen
into the tank water, did not know swimming, and, in the absence of
anyone to rescue him, died due to drowning. Subsequently, the Duty
Medical Officer, Government Hospital, Armoor, conducted a post-mortem
examination and issued a detailed post-mortem examination report,
wherein the cause of death was opined to be asphyxia due to drowning.
The opposite parties submitted that, as disclosed by the police
investigation and the statements of witnesses, statements recorded under
Section 180 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the call
detail records (CDRs) for the period from 01.11.2024 to 04.04.2025 the
deceased had consumed toddy with his acquaintances near the
Jakranpally tank bund before the incident.
The post-mortem examination report establishes drowning as the
cause of death. However, unless the report contains specific findings concerning alcohol consumption or intoxication, it cannot by itself
conclusively establish or disprove intoxication.

