Supreme Court – A Successful Resolution Applicant Cannot Be condemned Unheard.
Whether the NCLAT could invalidate a resolution plan approved during a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) without impleading or hearing the successful resolution applicant, whose rights would be directly affected by such an order
A judicial or quasi-judicial forum cannot invalidate an approved resolution plan or pass any order causing adverse civil consequences to a successful resolution applicant without impleading and hearing such successful resolution applicant.
Any appeal or application that seeks to invalidate, modify, or undermine a CoC-approved/NCLT-approved resolution plan must necessarily implead and hear the successful resolution applicant. An order passed in its absence is liable to be set aside for violation of natural justice, irrespective of the merits of the challenge.
From an IBC practitioner’s perspective, this judgment is less about the merits of the resolution plan and more about procedural safeguards during CIRP and appellate proceedings. Its implications are significant for Resolution Professionals (RPs), CoCs, successful resolution applicants (SRAs), and dissenting creditors
NCLT approved the resolution Plan of VLPL on 26.3.2025. However, the NCLAT allowed the appeal of NCLAT – minority financial creditor – challenging the Resolution without adding the successful Resolution Applicant as party to the appeal or without hearing.
Judgment dated 16.11.2026 of the Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No4171 of 2026 of Birendra Kumar Agrawal Vs. S2 Tech.com India Pvt Ltd and another with connected civil appeal.

