Suspension Beyond 90 days Without Review is Illegal – Rule 10(6) CCS (CCA) Rules
Suspension Beyond 90 days Without Approval of Review Committee – Illegal
Suspension Beyond 90 Days – Illegal – Rule 10(6) of CCS (CCA) Rules
The petitioner was suspended on 17.01.2025 and the period of 90 days was over on 17.4.2025. However, the suspension was not reviewed by the Review Committee and same was continued without review beyond 90 days.
In Union of India V/s. Dipak Mali (2010 (2) SCC 222), the Supreme Court has considered similar case and has recorded its conclusion that a subsequent review order of extension after the period of 90 days cannot legally amount to a period of extension of suspension.
Judgment dated 4.11.2026 of the High Court of Bombay at Goa in Writ Petition No.796 of 2026 of Honaji Arjun Morajkar Vs. State of Goa and another
On plain reading of Rule 10(6), it is clear that a suspension order may be reviewed on the recommendation of the Review Committee constituted for that purpose and orders may be passed extending the suspension only on such recommendation. It is not the case of the Director of Panchayats that the Review Committee considered the case of extension of the original order of suspension within the 90 days specified under Rule 10(6), but this is clearly a case where both further periods of suspension were extended after the initial elapsing of the 90 days.
Applying the ratio of the above judgment to the facts of the present case, clearly the initial suspension order which was issued on 17.01.2025 came to an end on 17.04.2025 on the lapse of 90 days. There was no review by the Review Committee during this period. Consequently, therefore, all further orders of suspension, i.e. order dated 29.07.2025 and 25.02.2026, would have no effect and they would be contrary to Rule 10(6) of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
This judgment reaffirms that Rule 10(6) of the CCS (CCA) Rules is mandatory, and failure to review suspension within 90 days results in automatic cessation of suspension. Administrative authorities cannot cure the defect through belated review orders. The ruling is particularly useful in service matters involving prolonged suspension of government servants

