Your CIBIL Score Matters – Consumer Forum Holds Lender Accountable for Faulty Reporting
Failure to Remove Name of Home Loan Co-Applicant from CIBIL Record & Compensation for Deficiency in Service
The ex-wife of the complainant had taken home loan from LIC Housing. The complainant – husband was added as co-applicant to the said loan.
However, after their divorce on 14.3.2016, the complainant filed divorce decree copy and requested LIC Housing to remove his name as co-applicant from the home loan. The ex-wife had given consent for the same.
However, his loan application dt.9/9/2016 with PNB was rejected as his name was still reflecting as a co-applicant in the CIBIL records.
Subsequently, onenquiring by the complainant, the Opposite Party confirmed vide e-mail dt. 31/1/2017 that his name was removed.
As per Sec.21 of the Credit Information Companies (Regulation) Act,
2005, and RBI guidelines, credit institutions (banks/NBFCs/HFCs)
are statutorily duty-bound to update correct credit data accurately
and promptly to Credit Information Companies
(CIBIL/Equifax/Experian/Crif High Mark). And in the instant case,
the facts and evidence on record clearly establishes that the
complainant’s name is still reflecting in the LIC HSG Housing Loan
Acc. No. 710600002087 in his CIBIL Score & Report ( running into
145 pages) filed by the complainant under Ex.A-2 dt.23/11/2024
which is undisputed and unrebutted by the Opposite Party. Although
the confirmation e-mail dt.31/1/2017 ( Ex.A-6) of the Opposite Party
states that the name of the complainant was deleted from the said
loan and further stated by the Opposite Party @ para 4 of their
written version that the said loan account itself was closed on
17/10/2017, as per the above referred Sec.21 of the Credit
Information Companies (Regulation) Act, 2005, and RBI guidelines,
merely removing the co-applicant’s name in internal records (Jan
2017) does not discharge the legal obligation of the Opposite Party.
Further on the contention that discrepancies in the CIBIL report are
outside the purview of the Opposite Party, the question is whether
the Opposite Party can disclaim responsibility by attributing the
discrepancy to CIBIL. The Opposite Party is the original reporting
institution in respect of the subject loan account and its
responsibility cannot necessarily end merely updating its internal
records. In fact, the Opposite Party is statutorily required to
communicate the revised loan status and transmit the updated
data/information to CIBIL and failure to update CIBIL records not
only results in erroneous information but also adversely impacts the
credit score/worthiness or the consumer/complainant herein.
Hence, the fact that the complainant’s name is still reflecting in the
10
LIC HSG Housing Loan Acc. No. 710600002087 in his CIBIL Score
& Report ( Ex.A-2 and @ page 141/145 under Ex.A-18) establishes
deficiency of service and violation of statutory obligation on the part
of the Opposite Party. Accordingly, this point is answered in favour
of the complainant and against the Opposite Party.
However, the complainant is entitled for reasonable compensation
for the anxiety, inconvenience and mental agony caused due to the
continued reflection of the complainant’s name as a co-applicant
from 2019 to 2025 in the CIBIL Report, owing to the failure of the
Opposite Party in communicating the revised loan status and
transmitting the updated data/information to CIBIL having deleted
his name and closed the loan account in 2016-2017.

