Arbitral Award – Incomplete Work Is Not Abandonment of Contract
Comments on the post of Bar Bulletin and the Order dated 11.11.2026 of the High Court at Madras in Original Petition No.680 of 2019 and Application No.4013 of 2024 of M/s. Appu Hotels Ltd vs. M/s Voltas Limited
Appu Hotels, through their consultant, invited bids from eligible bidders for the Heating, Ventilation and Air-Conditioning Systems (HVAC) and the installation of the Electrical System for their proposed ‘Le-Meridien Hotel’ at Coimbatore. The project includes the supply of materials, installation, testing and commissioning of the entire HVAC and electrical systems. Voltas Limited, being the successful bidder, was issued a work order on 11.05.2009 for a total contract value of Rs.11.80 Crores. The period of completion of the contract was eight months. Clause 1 of the work order deals with the scope of work; technical specifications are contained in Clause 2; prices are mentioned in Clause 3; terms of payment in Clause 5; completion period in Clause 6; dispute resolution through arbitration in Clause 8; testing and guarantee in Clause 11; and further specifications are annexed to the said work order.
As the project neared completion, disputes arose between the parties, resulting in claims and counterclaims concerning the completion or abandonment of the work, the balance amount payable under the final bill, the release of the retention amount to Voltas Limited, and the compensation claim made by Appu Hotels on the ground that it was compelled to engage third parties to complete the pending works. Disputes also arose regarding the obtaining of the final clearance from the Chief Electrical Inspector to Government (in short, ‘CEIG’). These disputes were followed by the issuance of legal notices, replies and rejoinder notices.

