Property Tax, Shop Licence & Electricity Bill Do not Legalise Illegal Structures
Property Tax, Shop LIcence, Electricity Bill Do not regularize Unauthorized Construction
Judgment dated 25.8.2026 of the High Court of Bombay in Writ Petition (L) No.22853 of 2026 with W.P.(L) No.22860 of 2026 (OS) of Shah Constructions Co. Ltd Vs. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and others
The legal position is no longer res integra. In Ashok Tukaram Ramugade vs. M.C.G.M. reported in 2026 SCC OnLine Bom 5080, this Court held that an unauthorised structure being subsequently assessed to property tax by the B.M.C. would not change the unauthorised character of the structure nor would it make the structure authorised from the date of assessment.
In Sidharam M. Yanagandul vs. State of Maharashtra reported in 2026 SCC OnLine Bom 971, affirmed by the Division Bench in Laxmi Gopinath Shetye vs. MHADA in Civil Writ Petition No.1546 of 1996 dated 13th March, 2024, it has been authoritatively held that assessment of an unauthorised structure to property tax neither alters its unauthorised character nor amounts to regularisation. In the present case the Petitioners have relied precisely upon such documents which reliance cannot be countenanced.
Besides the Assessment bills, electricity bills, shop and establishment licence or any other licence issued by the B.M.C. or any authority, cannot have the effect of rendering an unauthorised structure legal or authorised. The reliance placed on assessment bills, repair permissions, property tax receipts, electricity bills and licence issued by B.M.C. is wholly misplaced and cannot be used to prove the structure to be authorised.

